Can a pony tail palm grow/survive in just water?

A pony tail palm could survive for some time in just water, but it would not thrive.

Plants like pony tail palms need nutrients to be healthy and to grow.

Try 'Yates Specialty Potting Mix Plants & Ferns' as a specially formulated mix for most potted plants and ferns. The controlled release fertiliser added to this specialty mix will continuously feed your plants for up to 6 months. Click here for more info on this product: https://www.yates.com.au/product/potting-propagation/growing-media/yates-specialty-potting-mix-plants-ferns